Lest we forget: the fiscal cliff happened from 2001 to 2010


All of the gnashing of teeth and wringing of hands about the need to avert the US “fiscal cliff” in January is dishonest. The truth is that the fiscal cliff began in 2001 when the then Republican-led Congress committed to funding two foreign wars in Afghanistan and then Iraq without cutting offsetting spending in other areas but while rolling out a series of time-limited tax cuts cited as necessary to revive the private sector from the 2001-02 recession.

These programs became known as the “Bush tax cuts” and specifically were implemented via the Economic Growth and Tax Relief Reconciliation Act of 2001 (EGTRRA) and the Jobs and Growth Tax Relief Reconciliation Act of 2003 (JGTRRA). The Bush tax cuts as originally agreed had sunset provisions that made them expire at the end of 2010. When this deadline approached however, whether to renew the lowered rates, and how, became the subject of extended political gridlock wherein the Democrats proposed an extension for only those earning less than $250,000 and the Republicans refused to agree to a rate increase for those earning more than $250,000. This stalemate resulted in a further two-year extension of lowered tax collection that was part of a larger tax and economic package, dubbed the Tax Relief, Unemployment Insurance Reauthorization, and Job Creation Act of 2010. In the meantime, and since 2001, government spending has continued apace while revenue collection has continued at the lowest levels in more than 50 years. This has resulted in the US government’s escalating reliance on debt issuance to fund its commitments.

Those who argue that the resumption of higher tax rates are disastrous, anti-growth and anti-America, are also succumbing to unsubstantiated hyperbole. Most developed countries including Canada have been paying tax rates at or above the US rates slated to resume in 2013. The US itself was collecting similar and even higher rates during its longest and most prosperous economic expansion in history from 1982 to 1999.

So the next time someone argues that tax cuts and current spending levels must be extended now “or else” the country will suffer dire financial consequences, let us not succumb to partisan nonsense. The crisis is already here and it has been well earned by both sides. For most it will never seem like a good time to cut spending and resume more responsible tax collection. The truth is that the time has come for adults to do both.

Posted in Main Page | 5 Comments

Danielle on Money Talks with Michael Campbell

Danielle was a guest this morning on Money Talks radio with Michael Campbell talking about the outcome of the US election this week and what it may mean for investment markets. You can listen to an audio clip here at 9:00am November 10, by advancing the play bar to 7:00.

Posted in Main Page | Leave a comment

A “plutocrat” calls BS on his peer group

This article makes some honest points. Self-reflection from one on the “inside”, is always helpful. All humans must guard against our inclination to pull the ladder up after ourselves and our family in the struggle for prosperity.

NICK HANAUER is a Seattle-based serial entrepreneur, venture capitalist, author and activist with a knack for identifying and building transformative business models.

In 1995, Hanauer became the first non-family investor in Amazon.com where he served as a Board Advisor until January 2000. During the same time period, he founded and served as CEO of aQuantive, Inc (originally Avenue A Media) and a short time later founded Gear.com. aQuantive was acquired by Microsoft in August 2007 for $6.4 billion, the largest acquisition in Microsoft history, and Gear.com merged with Overstock.com in 2001.

He co-founded Second Avenue Partners in 2000, and he currently serves as a board member and advisor to MarketLeader.com and Qliance Medical Group and is vice chairman of Marchex.

See his recent article: A message from us rich Plutocrats to you little people, by Nick Hanauer:.

“People like me don’t hate Obama because he’s going to raise our taxes, although we hate that plenty. We hate him because his views about the importance and primacy of the middle class diminish our status. The threat he represents isn’t economic; it’s existential. It’s not just our pocket books that are threatened, but, more importantly, our prestige and our influence on this country. Our manhood is at stake.

Facts are for little people.

We plutocrats have a long and proud history of controlling human societies, and the belief systems that we create about how the world works enable us to do that. “Earth is the center of the solar system” was a useful one for us in the past. “Lowering taxes on the rich produces growth” is one of our current favorites. You show me an orthodox belief, and I’ll show you plutocrats who benefit from it.

Without me and my money, you wouldn’t even have a job.
We understand human nature well enough to know that people believe and accept ideas for all sorts of reasons, but rarely because of facts or evidence. Mostly, people believe what suits them, what makes them feel good. And what makes us feel good is a set of beliefs that reinforce our status, privileges and power.”

Posted in Main Page | 5 Comments